The Right Table Saw for
Your Shop
|
 |
|
Rockler offers a broad range of
table saws designed by Jet and Powermatic for
woodworkers of all budgets. |
Buying a table saw is one
of the biggest and most carefully considered investments a
woodworker can make. To make the best decision, you need to
know what your options are, and what's important to look for
in a table saw. In this article, we'll cover the
basic table saw facts, and point out a few things to
consider when you're shopping for a new saw.
Article Contents:
- Table
Saw Terminology
- Types of
Table Saws
- Choosing the
Right Saw for Your Shop
Table Saw
Terminology
Although the design,
quality and purpose of the table saws on the market varies
greatly, all table saws share certain basic
features: They all have a base, a table and extension wings,
rails and a rip fence, a motor, trunnions, gearing to raise
and tilt the blade, and an arbor and arbor assembly.
 |
|
The
Powermatic Model 4A picturedabove is an open
based saw. The motor is mounted to the back of the
saw and the bottom of the base is open. |
The Base
The base houses the working parts of the saw, including the trunnions,
the arbor assembly, the sector gears, and sometimes the
motor. On some saws, the base is a "cabinet" type, meaning
that a fully enclosed base extends all the way to the floor.
Other saws have an open base, meaning that the base
consists of an open metal box that surrounds the
internal working parts of the saw. Open base saws have legs
that extend from the bottom of the base to the floor.
Recently, a few "hybrid"
saws that combine the features of a cabinet base and an open
base have appeared on the market. These saws have legs,
but the base is enclosed on all sides to facilitate dust
collection and limit noise.
The Table and
Extension Wings
The table and extensions plays an extremely important role
in the overall performance of the saw. The table needs to
be reliably flat and durable to properly support the
workpiece being cut. Cast iron is the material of choice for
the table and extensions. on a quality saw, the table is
made using state of the art foundry methods and is precision
ground to flatness in the .0005'' tolerance range.
Table extension wings bolt
on to the right and left sides of the table and increase the
surface area of the saw to help support wide stock and sheet
materials. On a heavy duty stationary saw, the extensions
are usually cast iron, while on smaller saws, they may be
made of lighter stamped steel or the lighter "webbed" style
of cast iron.
One drawback of
lighter-weight table extensions is that they - of course -
have less mass, and the overall mass of the saw is what
soaks up the vibration crated by the motor and other moving
parts. The added mass of heavy cast iron extension
wings decreases vibration, which in turn helps the saw stay
in calibration, and, incidentally, helps it stay firmly
planted on the shop floor. On less expensive saws,
extensions made of stamped metal, or ones that aren't
precision ground, can also compromise the overall flatness
of the table surface.
 |
|
The fence system
offered standard with the
Jet JWSS Supersaw (above) and many Powermatic
contractor saws are patterned after the famous
Biesemeyer design, bringing the accuracy and
reliability of a professional-class fence system to
affordable contractor and hybrid saws. |
The Rip Fence and Rails
The rip fence guides the wood
as it is being ripped (cut along it's length) and can be
positioned to any width of cut within the saw's range.
The fence rides on fence rails attached to the front and
rear edge of the table. Ideally, the system keeps the fence
perfectly parallel to the plane of the blade, regardless of
where the fence is positioned.
The quality and accuracy of
fence systems, however, varies greatly across the spectrum.
The quality of a table saw's fence system is an extremely
important consideration: A poorly designed or inaccurate
fence greatly diminishes the quality and accuracy of the
cut, and can be a source of significant frustration. For
saws in the price range of most hobbyists, the famous
Biesemeyer T-square fence design sets the standard. Fence
systems like the Jet XACTA and Powermatic's Accu-Fence are
the norm on professional-class stationary saws and, happily,
are also available many smaller and less costly Jet and
Powermatic models.
The Miter
Gauge
Most table saws use the miter gauge and miter slot system to
allow for crosscutting. A miter gauge consists of a cast
metal protractor head attached to a length of metal bar. The
bar rides in corresponding "miter slot" in the table saw's
surface. Protractor on the "no frills" miter gauges that
come with most table saws can be set to crosscut stock at
any angle between 90 and 30 degrees and, if well made, do a
serviceable job with most "routine" crosscutting.
 |
|
Most table saws
come standard with a serviceable, no-frills miter
gauge. The optional slide table and upgraded miter
gauge on the
Jet JWSS Supersaw adds precision crosscutting
features, including a cam-lock material clamp and
positive stops for common angles to the standard
package. |
One of the more useful add-ons
for just about any table saw is either an upgraded system
offered by the manufacturer, or an aftermarket miter gauge
or crosscutting sled. These tools provide, in various
combinations, repeatable incremental angle positioning,
longer fences, stop blocks and other advanced features that
can come in handy in projects that call for precision
crosscutting.
The Motor,
Trunnions, and Arbor Assembly
The motor, trunnions, arbor assembly, and gearing make up
the essential mechanical components of the saw. These
quality and robustness of these components vary considerably
from saw to saw and can greatly impact the durability of the
saw and it's capacity for cutting heavy stock and it's
ability to stay in adjustment and hold settings.
Most table saws - other
than "jobsite" and bench top models - are equipped with
induction type motors in the 1 - 5 HP
range. On better quality saws, you'll find a "totally
enclosed fan cooled" (TEFC) induction motor, which makes
sense, because a TEFC motor is sealed against dust and other
contaminants (a significant advantage in a woodshop) and is
designed for continuous duty.
Saws specifically designed
for hobbyists and home use are usually outfitted with motors
under 3 HP and can be operated on standard 110
volt residential circuitry. In general, motors in this
class are powerful enough for routine cutting of sheet goods
and hardwoods up to 1'' thick. Professional class saws, on
the other hand, have motors in the 3- 5 HP range and require
a 220 volt power supply. Motors in this category are
designed to stand up to hours and hours of continuous duty,
and have enough power to cut even thick, heavy hardwood
stock without bogging down.
The arbor assembly
is made up of the arbor and the sector gear for raising and
lowering the blade. The arbor is the shaft that holds the
blade and, on all American stationary saws that use a 10''
blade, is 5/8'' in diameter where the blade is attached. On
some larger and higher quality saws, the arbor is larger in
diameter through the bearings to allow for more substantial
bearings, and is turned down to 5/8'' to accommodate the
blade. The sector gear is an arc shaped gear that operates
in conjunction with a worm gear attached to an adjustment
wheel to raise and lower the blade. The gearing on better
saws includes an adjustment mechanism to take up slack in
the gearing and limit backlash.
The front and rear trunnions
- along with the yoke, which joins the two - are what hold
the motor and arbor assembly in place. The trunnions are of
interest because they are what hold the blade in alignment
with the rip fence and miter slot, and also because they
play a role in absorbing vibration form the motor and blade
and transferring it to the mass of the saw's base and table.
Trunnions with a "wide stance" (trunnions that span most of
the width of the base have a wide stance) tend to improve
the stability of the arbor assembly. The general rule of
thumb is: the better the saw, the more substantial the
trunnions.
Also, it's important to
consider whether the trunnions mount to the base of the
saw or the underside of the table. Trunnions that mount to
the base (the standard on professional-class saws)
make aligning the blade with the miter slot and fence
much easier: The motor, arbor assembly, trunnions and base
stay bolted together as a single unit while the table is
brought into alignment with the blade, rather than awkward
prospect of having to loosen the trunnions assembly from the
bottom of the table and bring it into alignment with the
table top.
Types of Table Saws
Table saws
available on the market today fall into a number of classes:
jobsite saws, compact saws, contractor saws, hybrid saws and
cabinet saws. For woodworkers, the last three -
contractor, hybrid, and
cabinet table saws are of the most interest. While
improvements in recent years to "jobsite" saws and compact
saws have made them more viable for a number of carpentry
tasks, they simply lack the power and accuracy to suit
the needs of the professional or serious hobbyist
woodworker.
 |
|
The Powermatic
Model 4A is a "classic" contractor saw with high-end
features, including an Accu Fence rail and fence
system and cast iron extension wings. |
Contractor Saws
Contractors were originally designed to be portable enough
to hauled from jobsite to jobsite. These open-based table
saws are characterized by a straightforward design and an
affordable price. Contractor saws are relatively
lightweight (in the 250 - 350 lb. range) and usually priced
within the reach of the hobbyist and homeowner and, until
recently, have been virtually the only option for the small
shop.
Contractor saws do make a
few concessions in the name of affordability and
portability. Although most contractor saws have a solid cast
iron table top, the extension wings may be made of "open
webbed" cast iron or stamped metal. The trunnions,
gearing and arbor assembly of a contractor saw are less
husky than those found on more expensive saws. The
contractor saw's motor hangs off of the back of the saw - a
feature originally meant to make the motor easier to remove
for transport - and is most often connected to the arbor
assembly via a single V-belt.
Contractor saws are
still the most affordable solution for the home shop, and
are suitable for carpentry, small cabinetry projects, trim
work, and basic furniture making. Many contractor saws now
come with high quality fence systems. Using the best quality
saw blade - and using blades designed for a specific type of
cut - can enhance the performance of a contractor saw and
bring it up to speed for many more advanced woodworking
projects. Buying a contractor saw that's equipped with solid
cast iron extension wings will increase the stability of the
saw, and help reduce the impact of vibration on the saw's
less substantial trunnions and gearing.
 |
|
Jet and Powermatic
cabinet saws offer performance and durability the
put them in a class by themselves. The
Jet JTAS pictured above comes standard with
everything you'd expect from a professional-class
saw, plus a few extra options and features, like the
XACTA router lift that lets your table saw double as
a router table, and a left-tilt blade for increased
beveling accuracy and safety. |
Cabinet Saws
Cabinet saws - so called
because of the fully enclosed "cabinet" style base -
represent the other end of the spectrum from the contractor
saw. Cabinet saws are designed to meet the performance and
durability needs of professional woodworkers. Cabinet saws
are more substantial in overall construction than contractor
saws - they're built using more cast iron and steel, have
heavier trunnions, gearing, and arbor assemblies, and more
powerful motors than their contractor saw counterparts. The
cumulative result is a saw that can cut through even the
thickest hardwood stock easily, all day long, with very
little vibration to wear on either the saws alignment and
settings or the operator's nerves.
A number of features set
the cabinet saw apart: The motor is enclosed inside the
cabinet base, making it a quieter saw, and the fully
enclosed base itself has the advantage of making dust
collection an easier matter. The motor and arbor assembly
are held in place with heavy duty trunnions that attach to
the cabinet base, instead of the table, making it much
easier to bring the saw blade into alignment with the miter
slot and fence. Cabinet saw are, in general, manufactured to
more exacting standards than less expensive saws: their
tables are flatter, their bearings and pulleys heavier and
more robust, and most often, they're equipped with a more
reliable fence system.
A good quality cabinet saw
is more of an investment than contractor saw, however. And
because cabinet saws use more powerful motors (3 -5 HP as
opposed to 1 - 1-3/4 HP for contractor and hybrid saws) they
require a 220 volt circuit for operation. They are by no
means portable - a full sized cabinet saw weighs in at
upwards of 600 lbs. But even with the greater expense, the
electrical power requirements, and the physical heft of the
machine, because of their superior performance, cabinets
saws are still the preferred saw of professional woodworkers
and serious amateurs alike.
 |
|
Hybrid saws, like
the
Jet JWSS pictured here, combine affordability
with cabinet saw features, including a fully
enclosed base and heavier trunnions and gearing and
more advanced drive belt systems. |
| |
Hybrid Saws
In recent years, tool manufacturers have begun to recognize
the gulf between the affordable contractor saw and
the cabinet saw, and have responded by developing a new
class of table saw. "Hybrid" table saws capture some of the
most valuable features of the cabinet saw at a price that's
still in range for the hobbyist.
Some hybrid saws have a
cabinet type of base and others have a shorter base
and legs, but in either case, the base is fully enclosed,
with the motor mounted inside the base, instead of on the
back of the saw. Hybrid saws are equipped with more
substantial trunnions and arbor bearings, often a
more advanced drive belt system, and better gearing than
most contractor saws. In addition, the trunnions of many
hybrid saws are mounted to the base of the saw, making
precision alignment of the blade with the miter slot and the
blade much easier.
Hybrid saws are essentially
a scaled down version of the cabinet saw. They're lighter
weight, and are equipped with motors in the 1-1/2 - 1-3/4 HP
range (which means that they can be used with standard 110
volt service). Many believe that hybrid saws represent the
wave of the future for home shops, and while they're not
quite in the same class as their larger cousins, hybrid saws
are sturdy and well constructed, and offer many advantages
for the serious hobbyist.
Choosing the Right Saw for
Your Shop
The type of saw to
consider for your shop depends on the type of woodworking
you do, the amount of time you spend woodworking, your
budget and, in part, the space and type of access your shop
affords (you should think twice, for example, before
committing yourself to moving a full scale cabinet saw into
a small basement shop).
If you spend only a few hours
a week in your shop, mostly making small cabinetry and craft
projects, a cabinet saw might be nice to have, but a little
more than you need. On the other hand, if you operate a
small professional shop, and are looking for a saw that you
can comfortably and reliably run for hours at a time, a low
end contractor model will probably slow you down and end up
being a disappointment. Hybrid saws offer a good middle
ground for serious hobbyists, and will even prove suitable
for certain small-scale professional operations. Jet Tools
offers a surprising breadth of advanced features in its line
of affordable "Supersaws."
As important as the type of
saw you choose are the individual features of the saw. Some
affordable contractor model saws offer many of the same
features that you'd expect to find on a top-quality cabinet
saw, such as the widely respected Accu-Fence system
and precision ground cast iron table tops and extension
wings you'll find on Powermatic contractor models. By the
same token, while saws in the cabinet saw class all share
certain features - a 3HP or larger motor, trunnions that
attach to the base, and heavier construction - they are not
all manufactured to the same standards. Take a close look
at the quality of all of the saw's components, including
the quality of the fence system, the mass and stance of the
trunnions, the grind and finish of the top and extension
wings, and features that make power transmission to the
blade more efficient.
Buying a table saw is a big
investment, and worth careful consideration. You may not be
able to "test drive" every table saw on your list, but you
can read reviews, compare specs and features, and it
doesn't hurt to take the manufacturers reputation into
account. When you're ready to buy your new dream table saw,
Rockler offers a wide variety of
contractor saws,
hybrid saws and
cabinet saws from Jet and Powermatic, two of the most
trusted names in the business. |